Page 1153 in LogueTown
first Latest
Page 1153

first Previous Next Latest
Average Rating: 5
Number of people who have voted: 3

By the same author as Grand Line 3.5



1st Jun 2018, 1:39 AM

Totally worth it...if only for the pure cool factor of getting to look like the Tasmanian Devil for a few seconds. Still be totally worth it.

edit delete reply


2nd Jun 2018, 7:31 AM

i agree.

edit delete reply


1st Jun 2018, 1:44 AM

Hey, Sanji learns the Tatsumaki later too!

edit delete reply


1st Jun 2018, 11:53 AM

Here's my question. Not a criticism, nor complaint; just genuinely curious about the subject...

Why Carmen?

Smoker and Tashigi are at least somewhat recurring characters in the anime; the crew encounter them again sometime down the line. But Carmen is purely a filler encounter, same as Daddy Masterson, and we will never see her or her ilk ever again. Her encounter in canon does not even advance Sanji's goals or character in any meaningful way, except as an obstacle to the elephant carp or whatever which was the real MacGuffin for that episode.

I suppose it's less interesting for Sanji, a DM character, to interact with another NPC in this scene, but I think Amethyst's player (whose name escapes me, sorry) deserves better than to roll a new character each time the two crews have a crossover.

edit delete reply


1st Jun 2018, 12:42 PM

i don't think she'll roll a new character "each time", just the next time they encounter each others. (now that's only my suposition, but i think she'll be Hina the Black cage. her sorta' harsh personality fit with Marceline i think.)
Now, why Carmen? well, you said it yourself, it would'nt make much sense for Sanji who is a GMPC to be having a challenge with a NPC, so she had to be a PC. in addition to this, it allow to introduce Phoebe, Marceline and Bonnie at the same time. then at the end of the session, after trying it out against Sanji, she decide that she'll play another one later, and the next time thoses three come back (that's Alabasta), she roll this new character and introduce her.
(now Hina is'nt here as often as Smoker and Tashigi, but after all, nothing tell say that they have to always come back all three of them together)

edit delete reply

Emperor Megaman

21st Jul 2021, 6:16 PM

Other option would be that she doe'nt come back in Alabasta, but ends up playing Law.
Now the only reason i envisage that option is that Law come back at the same time as Tashigi and Smoker. Otherwise, since he is introduced in Shabaody with Kid, i guess he could be played by another guest, or new character from this comic.
the fact that he stick around for much longer than a simple "guest" and is given nearly as much importance as a Straw-hat, so i think it will mak more sense if he is played by a main character from this comic rather than a guest.

edit delete reply

Leave a Comment